Reconsidering “Cinéma Vérité” and “Direct Cinema”: The Modes and Strategies of Documentary Filmmaking in Hong Kong Protest Documentaries Yellowing and Inside the Red Brick Wall
Author : Ting-Ying Lin
Keywords : Hong Kong cinema, Hong Kong protest documentaries, cinéma, vérité, direct cinema, Yellowing, Inside the Red Brick Wall
Shifting the focus from the prevalent issues including the environmental, political, and historical connections that have been extensively explored in the recent scholarship on Hong Kong protest documentaries, this article reconsiders and reevaluates the less-examined domain of documentary filmmaking paradigms, with a particular emphasis on “cinéma vérité” and “direct cinema.” It focuses on the analysis of two pivotal Hong Kong protest documentaries, Yellowing, centered on the 2014 Umbrella Movement, and Inside the Red Brick Wall, which documents the events during the 2019 Anti-Extradition Bill Movement. This article investigates how the two documentaries manifest the distinctive characteristics of cinéma vérité and direct cinema respectively, shedding light on the modes and strategies of documentary filmmaking in these two works. More specifically, the first section of the article critically examines Yellowing, illustrating how this documentary embodies the participatory, reflexive, and interventionist dimensions of cinéma vérité, reassessing the problems and limitations of this paradigm in documentary filmmaking. In the second section, the focus shifts to Inside the Red Brick Wall, which examines the observational approach of direct cinema employed by the filmmakers and how this documentary transcends the conventions of direct cinema through the documentary filmmakers’ editorial and transformative strategies. Ultimately, this article argues that these two representative Hong Kong protest documentaries, Yellowing and Inside the Red Brick Wall, embody the characteristics of cinéma vérité and direct cinema respectively, offering a perspective through which to analyze the relation between documentary filmmaking techniques and the representation of reality. By explicating these two exemplars of Hong Kong cinema, this article seeks to provide theoretical contributions with critical insights into the paradigms of cinéma vérité and direct cinema.