Yetan suilu: Casual Records of Night Talks
Author : Charles E. Hammond
Keywords : Yetan suilu, He Bang’e, Qing stories, fiction, Legends, classical narratives, oral narratives, Zi bu yu, supernatural phenomena, belief
DOI :
Modern readers tend to assume that He Bang’e’s (fl. 1736-
ca. 1779) Yetan suilu (Casual Records of Night Talks) are
fictional—the products of an author's creative imagination.
However, a close reading of the stories in this collection, with
reference to other collections of such supernatural stories,
demonstrates that such stories were believable for their
audience, and that the anthologists wrote down the stories they
heard from others. In other words, the stories are in fact
legends—stories heard from others, which the narrator and his
audience nevertheless believe are factual. Indeed, the content
of several stories demonstrates that, judged by Chinese
standards of the day, the material was generally believable.
At the same time, many a legend mentions the narrator
who recounted the story to He Bang’e, and a few of the legends
even appear in a contemporary’s book. Moreover, Bang’e
repeatedly cites by name a friend of his who tells some of the
stories to him, comments upon others, and apparently even
presented some of his own in writing. Similarly, at the end of
many legends describing unusual phenomena, he often
appends explanations or reactions to the given phenomenon,
generally demonstrating his belief in it. Others he explicitly
identifies as legends. In his own preface to this book, he says
that he has talked about such topics while drinking at night with
his friends, and what he says in several stories further
corroborates that telling such stories at night was a common
program of evening entertainment. In fact, the book seems to be
just what he calls it—Casual Records of Night Talks.