Local and Presentist Ecocritical Shakespeare in East Asia
Author : Iris Ralph
Keywords : Akira Kurosawa, Ming-chin Tsai, Shakespeare, Romeo and Juliet, Macbeth, butterflies, deforestation, ecocriticism, localism, presentism
In studies that focus on the phenomenon of Shakespeare in Asia, scholars
argue that a great deal of it has little to do with promoting serious intellectual
discourse and pressing cultural commentary and much to do with showing
off knowledge of the English language and one of its greatest purveyors.
Shen Lin voices that argument in an essay that focuses on Shakespeare in China,
where lavish and expensive mainstream productions of Shakespeare are catering
to a socio-political class, “the new patricians of the People’s Republic,” who
are eager to acquire and display knowledge of a “Shashibiya” that is “thematically”
out of tune “with contemporary Chinese reality.” Similarly, Rustom
Bharucha characterizes the phenomenon of Shakespeare in Asia as the desperate
attempt by “Old England . . . to cover its colonial past by seeking . . .
new reclamations of Shakespeare in Asian performance traditions, both traditional
and contemporary.” Although other scholars, notable among them
Bi-Qi Beatrice Lei, hold that Shakespeare in the East has pushed Shakespeare
into territory that is very different from older terrain marked by overtures
to the West, Lin and Bharucha make clear that more politically and culturally
relevant work needs to be done in “doing” Shakespeare in Asia. Taking
them at their word, I do that in this essay by ecocritically reading a film adaptation
of Macbeth, Japanese director Akira Kurosawa’s Throne of Blood, and
a film adaptation of the classical Chinese legend of “the Butterfly lovers,”
directed by Taiwanese director Ming-chin Tsai and commonly known as the
Chinese version of Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet. Ecocritic Robert Pogue
Harrison’s reading of “deforestation” in Macbeth is the main source of inspiration
for my discussion of Kurosawa’s film and the history of ecocide of East
Asian forests by local governments and later by multi-national companies in
the time between Japan’s Middle Ages, the time period in which Kurosawa’s
Macbeth is set, and the present century. Tsai’s film carries a haunting ecocidal
reference, one that the director may not have consciously intended but is powerful
no less, to the history of butterflies in Taiwan.